Payroll often looks simple when everything runs smoothly.
Payslips go out. People get paid. No one complains. Seems simple, right? But the routine of monthly payroll checks hides a lot that is going on underneath the surface employers don't see when they outsource their payroll to a reputable company.
Most payroll problems don’t come from obvious mistakes.
They come from missing monthly payroll checks that quietly go unnoticed, until HMRC, a pension provider, or an employee spots something months later.
Good payroll providers don’t just process payslips.
They review, sense-check, and reconcile payroll every month to catch issues early.
Here are seven monthly payroll checks that well-run providers carry out and that many employers never see happening.
1. RTI submissions match payroll reports
Submitting an FPS to HMRC is not the same as submitting the correct information.
Proper monthly payroll checks compares:
- Payroll reports
- Year-to-date figures
- What was actually sent to HMRC under RTI
This helps catch:
- Duplicate submissions
- Late or amended FPS files
- Differences between payroll software and HMRC records
Left unchecked, these issues can cause tax mismatches that only appear at year end.
For a clear overview of HMRC’s reporting requirements, see HMRC’s guidance on reporting payroll to HMRC: https://www.gov.uk/running-payroll/reporting-to-hmrc
2. Tax codes and NI categories are reviewed for anomalies
Tax code changes happen all the time, but not all of them make sense.
A good provider reviews:
- Sudden or unusual tax code changes
- Incorrect NI categories after promotions or age changes
- Directors or long-serving employees being moved incorrectly
This is one of the most important payroll compliance checks, as small errors here can affect both employee pay and employer liabilities.
3. Statutory payments are tracked and reviewed
Statutory payments are an easy place for mistakes to creep in.
Monthly payroll checks should confirm:
- Correct start and end dates
- Accurate recovery amounts
- No overpayments continuing after entitlement ends
This applies to:
- Statutory Sick Pay (SSP)
- Maternity, Paternity, Adoption and Shared Parental Pay
Problems here often go unnoticed until an HMRC review.
4. Pension contributions reconcile with the pension provider
Submitting pension data does not mean it has been received or applied correctly.
A proper payroll check confirms:
- Payroll deductions match pension uploads
- Employer contributions are correct
- The pension provider’s records match payroll
This is especially important where files are uploaded manually rather than via an API connection.
5. Salary changes and one-off payments are sense-checked
Backpay, bonuses, pay rises and leavers all increase risk.
A monthly review looks at:
- Unexpected pay spikes or drops
- One-off payments processed correctly
- Termination payments treated properly for tax
This check often prevents uncomfortable conversations with employees later.
6. Year-to-date figures are reviewed for drift
Payroll errors rarely happen in one big moment.
They build slowly.
Reviewing year-to-date figures each month helps spot:
- Rounding issues
- Repeating small errors
- Inconsistencies across periods
Catching this early avoids painful corrections at year end.
7. Approval and audit trails are recorded
Finally, good payroll providers document what happened.
This includes:
- Client approval of payroll reports
- Submission confirmations
- Clear audit trails showing who approved what, and when
If a query ever arises, this paperwork matters.
Why monthly payroll checks matter for growing businesses
For employers with 20–200 staff or more, payroll risk increases as the business grows.
More people means:
- More changes
- More edge cases
- More opportunity for small errors to multiply
Monthly payroll checks turn payroll from a reactive task into a controlled process.
Payroll checks – common questions
What are monthly payroll checks?
Monthly payroll checks are routine reviews carried out after payroll processing to confirm accuracy, compliance, and consistency across payroll, HMRC, and pension records.
Are monthly payroll checks a legal requirement?
There is no single rule requiring named “monthly checks”, but employers are legally responsible for payroll accuracy. Regular checks are how compliant providers manage that risk.
Does my payroll provider already do this?
Some do. Many don’t, or only check when something goes wrong.
If you’re unsure, it’s worth asking what checks are performed each month.
What happens if payroll checks aren’t done?
Errors may:
- Build up unnoticed
- Affect employee trust
- Lead to HMRC or pension provider issues later
Most problems are easier to fix early than months down the line.
Final thought
If you never see these checks, it doesn’t automatically mean they aren’t happening.
But good payroll providers are usually happy to explain how they keep things accurate, not just confirm that payroll has been run.
At Crystal, these monthly payroll checks are built into our process, not added after something breaks.
Download our free payroll checklist:
If this was useful, below are some of our recent posts:
- The 7 Monthly Payroll Checks Good Providers Run (That Most Employers Never See)
- HR and Payroll Data Check's Every Employer Should Do (Before Small Errors Become Big Problems)
- Can You Change Payroll Mid-Tax Year? Yes – Here’s How
- How Much Should Payroll Cost in the UK? A Clear and Honest Guide
- Winter workplace wellbeing and resilience
